theEucharist

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Wednesday, March 6, 2013

Does the Lectionary Mark a Rupture?

Posted on 6:42 AM by Unknown


Is there a real divide between the theology expressed the two forms of the Roman Rite? Pope Benedict would have denied it

In many ways there are so many similarities between the two that when both are celebrated in Latin, the language the Second Vatican Council expected Mass to be celebrated (though remember: until Trent the Latin Rite wasn't always in Latin - Greek was used in  Athens which was Latin Rite) and when it is celebrated ad orientem, as the Council and even the Missal of Paul VI expects (which in some Roman churches had never happened because of the Confessio before the altar), apart from prayers at the foot of the altar, which happens before the Mass actually begins, visually there are only slight differences. Not all of us have dancing and balloons at Mass! Indeed it could well be argued, as Paul VI does in the Preface to his Missal that Novus Ordo, is indeed an "organic development".

So what is the major difference? I touched on this in my last post and I think is worth highlighting and asking for comment, I said:
Celebrating the Traditional Mass every Sunday, I can't help being struck by how often the Epistle refers to the evil of "fornication", "adultery" and last Sunday, "sin that should not even be mentioned among you", these extracts seem to be rare in the OF Lectionary, or is that just my lack of attention?
It is not something I have thought of much, and certainly not something I have studied, and really it is only a bothersome thought. Certainly the OF Lectionary gives us a broader selection of readings, including the Old Testament and extracts from the Gospels other than mainly Matthew and chunks of John. In many ways the modern Lectionary is superior, as a logical academic presentation of scripture the older form is obviously inferior.
I don't know quite how the older Lectionary emerged, presumably like most organic forms, by a process of evolution and to meet pastoral needs, it was tried a tested in the crucible of sacred history down the centuries.
What is more significant and worthy of serious discussion is the rupture that I would suggest the newer Lectionary has introduced into the Church's presentation of the image of God. The pre-Concilliar image of God is different from the post-Concilliar image.
Revelation is both Scripture and Tradition, it is within the Liturgy that Revelation is presented: by changing the Lectionary have we broken with something very important?
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • The Nuncii
    I was chatting to a couple of Irish friends yesterday, both rather spontaneously said in the words of the second, "Charlie Brown: he...
  • SSPX's Problems
    Recently the SSPX Bishop Tissier de Mallerais revealed during a conference a letter written by Benedict XVI which says an agreement between ...
  • Come to judge the quick and the dedde
    One of the problems of being an aging and solitary celibate is not having a wife or superior to nag you about visiting the doctor; I wasn...
  • Thoughts on the new Prefect of the CDF
    One of my parishioners a nice young single mum was discreetly picking up cigarette ends in the street. She is addicted, she can't afford...
  • More on Müller
    Following on from a post yesterday of the new CDF Prefect, there was an interview on Vatican Radi o with Archbishop Gerhard Ludwig Müller. ...
  • Lello Scorzelli's Ferula: a return to the past
    Broken, tortured, twisted, contorted are the words that come to mind looking at this crucifix. It has the sense of  being in flux, half-form...
  • Norah Out!
    Apparently Ma Popehater can't understand  why Clifton diocese's favourite theologian Professor Norah Batty - head of Cleggy studies ...
  • Orbis Volvitur
    Crux stat dum orbis volvitur The Cross stands still the Earth revolves In monastic life a great deal revolved around the Exaltation of the H...
  • Vocations: thoughts
    I am a bit anxious about our parish's liturgical future, we are loosing our Master of Ceremonies, he believes God is calling him to the ...
  • "Vatican II: A discussion that can no longer be stopped"
    Under the heading, "Vatican II: A discussion that can no longer be stopped".  The excellent Rorate Caeli says: Whatever might be s...

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (206)
    • ►  September (11)
    • ►  August (13)
    • ►  July (29)
    • ►  June (32)
    • ►  May (21)
    • ►  April (17)
    • ▼  March (33)
      • No Feet instead an offering for the poor
      • Good Friday Sermon
      • A Society of Robbers or the Church?
      • A Jesuit Pope and the Two Standards
      • Why Have You Forsaken Me?
      • We are Brothers
      • Francis might teach us to be good
      • Larger than life Popes?
      • Veiling the Faith
      • Vatican Wealth in perspective
      • Inauguration: An Orthodox Reaction
      • I used to wash the feet of the poor
      • An Atheist Explains
      • Poverty: what is it?
      • Mahony Tweets
      • Ann Furse RIP
      • Pope bans Cardinal
      • Bartholomew is coming to the Inauguration
      • House Built on Rock or Sand?
      • Francis of Rome
      • Pope Francis
      • White Smoke
      • This is Jesus, the reality, Chimney Watchers
      • Some Papal Speculations
      • Crucifixion of Benedict XVI
      • Now what is this saying?
      • Silver Laden Mules
      • Does the Lectionary Mark a Rupture?
      • Violent and Abusive
      • Gloria TV Intimidated
      • Who Knew?
      • Giving the Faith Back
      • Diary Entry
    • ►  February (35)
    • ►  January (15)
  • ►  2012 (294)
    • ►  December (43)
    • ►  November (38)
    • ►  October (41)
    • ►  September (40)
    • ►  August (30)
    • ►  July (25)
    • ►  June (25)
    • ►  May (26)
    • ►  April (26)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile