theEucharist

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Friday, September 28, 2012

"Vatican II: A discussion that can no longer be stopped"

Posted on 1:46 PM by Unknown

Under the heading, "Vatican II: A discussion that can no longer be stopped". The excellent Rorate Caeli says:
Whatever might be said about the current situation of the talks between the Vatican and the Society of St. Pius X (SSPX), and whatever one's doctrinal position might be, one thing is clear: the frank discussion of the ambiguities of Vatican II and of post-Conciliar Vatican documents vis-a-vis the pre-Conciliar Magisterium has begun, and can no longer be stopped. While it would be easy to exaggerate the quality, extent and openness of the discussion so far, it cannot be denied that signs of it have been appearing in unlikely places, such as the following article that was published last week by the Homiletic and Pastoral Review.
It is interesting that the article deals essentially with mission or evangelisation, read the whole article, but it ends rather damningly:
The church has failed miserably in her missionary mandate, not because of laziness or a lack of numbers. Rather, it is because she has quite simply lost sight of her own mandate. She doesn’t know, for example, whether to convert non-Catholics to the one true faith, or to merely wish them well in the safe haven of their own religious beliefs. Vatican II sanctions both opposing views as equally necessary. It is as if the Catholic Church is just one of many other churches, all of which need to “converge” toward a total Christ who is immanent in all denominations. 
More and more, Catholics are shying away from using terms like “proselytizing,” “conversion,” and even “Catholic” in their ecumenical and inter-religious efforts, almost as if they were ashamed of the Gospel, or afraid of appearing as a “sign of contradiction.” In this confused state of diabolical disorientation, the Church has lost her ability to speak to the modern world about God with any clarity or conviction. She has, in fact, lost her salt, and become tasteless. 
Indeed, a kind of de-evangelization has set-in. In order to erase the prevalent indifferentism, and growing skepticism, among Catholics, the church needs to re-examine her relationship with the modern world, and clarify her understanding of Christian unity. Otherwise the Church’s missionary activity will be reduced to nothing more than literacy programs, irrigation schemes, agricultural improvements, and health services—that is, the advancement of civilization rather than religion.
Surely a failure to evangelise, to have the confidence in its message, is not merely a problem in itself which we suffer from today but it is a sign of the lack of health of the post Vatican II model of the Church, at least as it is lived out in those parts of the world where it is shrinking. The Church by its very nature is evangelistic if it is failing to produce fruit we must look to the root to find the disease.
I hope that one of the issues addressed by the forthcoming Synod on Evangelisation will be the reasons why we are failing to evangelise. The obvious answer must be the ambiguity, as this article points out, of Concilliar teaching.
Speaking of fruit, I heard of one seminary spiritual director, (guess where?) who was voted out of office by his monastic community who now tells his seminarians he is "as much a Moslem as Christian" and urges them to read the Koran as spiritual reading. That is better than another one, a Franciscan, who describes himself as "more a Buddhist than a Christian. Then of course there are those leading American nuns who have "moved beyond the Church and beyond Jesus".
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Lello Scorzelli's Ferula: a return to the past
    Broken, tortured, twisted, contorted are the words that come to mind looking at this crucifix. It has the sense of  being in flux, half-form...
  • A Jesuit Pope and the Two Standards
    "I will destroy the Church." "But the clergy have been doing that for the last two thousand years, and still they haven't...
  • 'Heirarchy' of truths
    A load of old nonsense is talked about the idea of "'heirarchy' of truths" by many who do not really understand Catholici...
  • Processional Thoughts
    Holy Week begins, and ends, with a procession. Processions were very much more significant in the pre-concillior Rites than they are in the ...
  • Shard
    Compare and contrast
  • Change?
    One of those light bulb jokes going the rounds a few years ago: "How many Oratorians does it take to change a light bulb?" Had sev...
  • Modern Ultramontanism: a Jesuit Problem
    Parishioners received a letter from the Provincial last weekend telling them the Jesuits are pulling out of their flagship parish of the Sa...
  • A Shove to the Right
    I used to know dozens of Conservative voters, now I know none, they have all become or say they will be UKIP voters. As one of our Bishops s...
  • Blogs and Gossip
    All means of communication are forbidden! This seems to be what Archbishop Nichols is suggesting in a recent sermon in a Mass for Pope Franc...
  • SSPX's Problems
    Recently the SSPX Bishop Tissier de Mallerais revealed during a conference a letter written by Benedict XVI which says an agreement between ...

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (206)
    • ►  September (11)
    • ►  August (13)
    • ►  July (29)
    • ►  June (32)
    • ►  May (21)
    • ►  April (17)
    • ►  March (33)
    • ►  February (35)
    • ►  January (15)
  • ▼  2012 (294)
    • ►  December (43)
    • ►  November (38)
    • ►  October (41)
    • ▼  September (40)
      • Ohio Nuns on Contraception
      • St Michael: the Cosmic Battle
      • "Vatican II: A discussion that can no longer be st...
      • SSPX's Problems
      • Bishop Egan's Pictures
      • Our Cunning Plans and God
      • Developing a cultus
      • Rotten Fruit
      • Bishop Egan's address to his new diocese
      • Congratulations to Bishop Egan
      • Musical Iconoclasts
      • Clare at Birmingham Oratory
      • Lib Dems in Brighton
      • More on Müller
      • What's going on at SMUC
      • An Excommunication this weekend
      • Thoughts on the new Prefect of the CDF
      • Bishops: Warriors or Diplomats
      • Catholic Patriarch: UN resolution that outlaws rel...
      • Are we serious as about Marriage?
      • Speaking as a bigot
      • Norah Out!
      • Mother of Sorrows, Pray for her
      • Happy Summorum Pontificum Day
      • Orbis Volvitur
      • A Prayer Request
      • Cardinal Heenan and the Hail Mary
      • On the list
      • Isn't this ghastly!
      • The Nuncii
      • Was Vatican I a Council of rupture?
      • Three Points about Cardinal Martini
      • Hope which is in you
      • Prayer in Adversity
      • In Praise of Diversity and the Irrational
      • Tina Beattie and fear at the Beda: what will "they...
      • Come to judge the quick and the dedde
      • Become a friend of Una Voce International
      • Primacy of Liturgical Law
      • Martini and the Left
    • ►  August (30)
    • ►  July (25)
    • ►  June (25)
    • ►  May (26)
    • ►  April (26)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile