theEucharist

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Tuesday, October 16, 2012

Saints and Airbrushing History

Posted on 5:08 AM by Unknown


The dying Emperor Augustus cried out, "I'm becoming a God!"
It strikes me dying Popes might cry out, "I am becoming a Beatus!"
Apparently Paul VI might be declared "Blessed" next year, John XXIII is already beatified as is John Paul II, there is strong lobby for Pius XII and of course John Paul I, I have always had a sneaking admiration for Pius XI but no-one else is that interested.
My Orthodox friends are horrified by the haste of some of our beatifications and canonisation, and so I am I. I am not sure what we mean any longer when we beatify someone or canonise them, in the past three criteria where necessary:

  1. They were in heaven: proved by miracles
  2. They had an enduring and wellfounded cultus
  3. Their holiness was outstanding and an example to the faithful
Obviously those who have been beatified and canonised fulfil all of these requirements, however there does seem to be a danger of writing history with an airbrush in our present day haste to raise certain individuals to the altar. Although in all cases there is holiness, in many there seem to be many other issues too. Too often beatification/canonisation can be seen as a political act, placing the Blesseds or Saints actions and words beyond question.
There is always the danger when the following generation beatify their benefactors, their teachers, friends, patrons and masters that it is ideas that are being raised to the altar rather than individuals, it is a piece of nepotism, even more worrying than that of the Borgias
In the case of St Jose-Maria Escriva who was certainly outstanding but with the extreme haste of his canonisation one wonders quite what influence Opus Dei and its money, and the political situation in Spain at the time of his death,  had on the speed of his canonisation. Would a great deal really have been lost by letting the euphoria following his death have settled down for a few decades and for his cultus to have bedded down more firmly in the Church outside of Opus Dei and Spain before his canonisation?
In the case of Pius XII there are obvious questions being asked both inside and outside the Church, not just about his wartime record but also about his private life, which seems to be a little eccentric: that nun, the monkey glands, for example. 
Paul VI, "Hamlet" as his predecessor called him, is possibly even more ambiguous, he certainly suffered, he lived with self-doubt all his life, he was too ill even to attend seminary, even in his lifetime there were rumours about blackmail, which were spread by his enemies, but which have never been answered. I wonder is it right for someone with so many enemies to be raised to the altar, shouldn't a reconciliation be necessary first?

I am not arguing for or against the raising to the altar of anyone, just simply expressing mistrust of  "Santo subito". Had Marcel Maciel's crimes been a little better hidden, it would not be difficult to imagine him carried to the altar by the money and enthusiasm of his followers. Again I ask would waiting a century do any harm? In the age of the global village would expecting "many" miracles, increasing the number be a problem? Would demanding a strong widespread and deep seated cultus be too much to ask?
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Lello Scorzelli's Ferula: a return to the past
    Broken, tortured, twisted, contorted are the words that come to mind looking at this crucifix. It has the sense of  being in flux, half-form...
  • A Jesuit Pope and the Two Standards
    "I will destroy the Church." "But the clergy have been doing that for the last two thousand years, and still they haven't...
  • 'Heirarchy' of truths
    A load of old nonsense is talked about the idea of "'heirarchy' of truths" by many who do not really understand Catholici...
  • Processional Thoughts
    Holy Week begins, and ends, with a procession. Processions were very much more significant in the pre-concillior Rites than they are in the ...
  • Shard
    Compare and contrast
  • Change?
    One of those light bulb jokes going the rounds a few years ago: "How many Oratorians does it take to change a light bulb?" Had sev...
  • Modern Ultramontanism: a Jesuit Problem
    Parishioners received a letter from the Provincial last weekend telling them the Jesuits are pulling out of their flagship parish of the Sa...
  • A Shove to the Right
    I used to know dozens of Conservative voters, now I know none, they have all become or say they will be UKIP voters. As one of our Bishops s...
  • Blogs and Gossip
    All means of communication are forbidden! This seems to be what Archbishop Nichols is suggesting in a recent sermon in a Mass for Pope Franc...
  • SSPX's Problems
    Recently the SSPX Bishop Tissier de Mallerais revealed during a conference a letter written by Benedict XVI which says an agreement between ...

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (206)
    • ►  September (11)
    • ►  August (13)
    • ►  July (29)
    • ►  June (32)
    • ►  May (21)
    • ►  April (17)
    • ►  March (33)
    • ►  February (35)
    • ►  January (15)
  • ▼  2012 (294)
    • ►  December (43)
    • ►  November (38)
    • ▼  October (41)
      • Liturgical Colours
      • Bishops Have Been Too Accomodating
      • Is it time for a new Missal?
      • Stripping of the Ceremonies: a Novus Ordo Problem
      • Outside of my comfort zone
      • Confraternity of Catholic Clergy
      • Not All Shall Have Prizes
      • Fanon shmanon
      • Blog from the Synod
      • Excessive Lourdes Water!
      • The Canadian Experience of Marriage Legislation
      • Manipulation of Language
      • Missing from the Synod: a Sign of Hope
      • What is needed?
      • So Much for Voltaire
      • Saints and Airbrushing History
      • Peasants, Plebs and Snobbery
      • Ecumenical [Οἰκουμενικόν] means "Worldwide"
      • Acts of Faith
      • Suggestions for the Year of Faith
      • Trying Corpses
      • Ecclesia Loquens:The Chattering Church
      • Return to the "letter" of the Council
      • Ann Widdecombe's Speech
      • I believe in the Resurrection because I believe in...
      • From Fr Armand de Malleray FSSP
      • Hunwicke is Back
      • Abp Müller to act on Soho Masses?
      • Tories Against Cameron's Redefinition of Marriage
      • The Eternal Sound
      • Its Never about Faith
      • Spirit of the Council stuff
      • Read what Abp Müller actually says
      • As in Francis' day, so today
      • Bishop Mark Davies: why they wore choir dress
      • From Mary’s Dowry a gentle New Evangelization
      • Sacra Liturgia 2013
      • Hollywood's new "big idea"
      • Dublin Pro-Abortion Rally
      • Modern Rites: Mormonism
      • A Few Thoughts on the Synod on Evangelisation
    • ►  September (40)
    • ►  August (30)
    • ►  July (25)
    • ►  June (25)
    • ►  May (26)
    • ►  April (26)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile